Franchise Failure Rates: What the Data Actually Shows

Decision Guide

Franchise Failure Rates: What the Data Actually Shows

SBA loan data, FDD Item 20 analysis, and what most franchise consultants won’t tell you
Published February 2026 | By Jason Ronnel

If you’ve spent any time researching franchise ownership, you’ve probably encountered the claim that franchises succeed at rates of 90 to 95 percent. That figure circulates widely, and it isn’t fabricated — it comes from real studies. But it is incomplete in ways that matter, and relying on it to assess risk would be a mistake.

Over the past several years I’ve reviewed hundreds of Franchise Disclosure Documents while helping entrepreneurs evaluate opportunities across the country. Questions about failure rates come up in nearly every serious conversation. The honest answer is that no single statistic captures franchise risk accurately — but the data we do have tells a useful story if you know how to read it.

Where the 90–95 Percent Figure Comes From

The widely repeated success rate traces back to studies that followed businesses already in operation and measured how many remained open after several years. The methodology sounds reasonable, but it has a significant flaw built in: businesses that closed very early often never appear in the sample at all. The dataset ends up measuring survivors rather than all franchises that opened during a given period. Measuring survivors and calling it a success rate is a bit like surveying marathon finishers and concluding that marathons are easy.

A more grounded benchmark comes from SBA loan performance data. The Small Business Administration finances a large volume of franchise purchases through its 7(a) loan program and tracks which borrowers default. Between 2010 and 2021, SBA franchise loans defaulted at an average rate of 9.9 percent across all franchisee categories — nearly one in ten, among a population of vetted borrowers who had to demonstrate solid credit, available capital, and a viable business plan just to qualify. The broader SBA portfolio across all small business industries shows a loan default rate of around 7.5 percent, based on a cohort of nearly 40,000 loans tracked from 2008 through 2023. Franchises as a group run slightly above that average.

Those numbers are more honest than the survival rate studies. But they still require context.

A Closed Franchise Isn’t Always a Failed One

This is a point that rarely gets made in these conversations, and it matters.

When a franchise closes, it gets recorded as a closure regardless of why it closed. A franchisee who retired after fifteen profitable years, one who sold the business to another operator, one who stepped away due to a health crisis, one who simply decided the lifestyle wasn’t what they wanted — all of those show up in aggregate data exactly the same way as a franchisee who ran out of money and had to shut the doors. Loan defaults similarly mix together weak business performance, undercapitalization, and personal circumstances that could affect any small business owner.

This doesn’t mean closure data should be dismissed. A 9.9 percent default rate is a real signal. But it does mean that raw numbers rarely tell the full story. The more useful question isn’t how many franchisees closed — it’s why they closed. That information lives in the Franchise Disclosure Document, not in any publicly available statistic.

Industries With the Lowest Default Rates

Despite the limitations of aggregate data, the industry-level picture is genuinely instructive. The table below shows loan default rates from SBA data covering loans originated between 2008 and 2012, tracked through mid-2023 across nearly 40,000 loans.

IndustrySBA Loan Default Rate
Funeral homes and funeral services2.11%
Veterinary services2.45%
Services for elderly and disabled individuals2.56%
Dental offices3.76%
Offices of therapists and audiologists3.95%
Private mail centers4.23%
Average for all franchise industries (2010–2021, separate SBA dataset)~9.9%

The pattern across these categories isn’t coincidental. Most require licensure or credentialing to operate, which limits competitive saturation and tends to attract operators with genuine qualifications. Demand is largely non-discretionary — people don’t postpone dental care or elder care because the economy softens. Most generate repeat business from an existing customer base rather than depending entirely on constant new customer acquisition. These structural characteristics are what drive the numbers.

The Same Logic Applies to Strong Home Services Categories

HVAC and home remediation — water damage, mold, fire restoration — don’t appear as their own line items in publicly available SBA industry tables, but they share the same structural profile that drives low default rates in the categories that do.

HVAC service is about as non-discretionary as a business gets. A failed furnace in January or a broken AC in August isn’t something homeowners schedule for later. Water damage and mold remediation operate the same way — these are emergency responses, not considered purchases. Both involve licensed technicians, which creates meaningful barriers to entry and supports sustainable pricing. Neither is vulnerable to e-commerce disruption or changes in consumer spending patterns, and both generate recurring maintenance revenue alongside emergency call volume. The structural profile looks far more like a dental practice than a restaurant, even though they’re commonly grouped into the same broad “service business” bucket.

Industries With the Highest Default Rates

The flip side of this picture is equally worth understanding. Franchise categories that show up most consistently in high-default data share the opposite structural profile: discretionary consumer spending, high buildout or overhead costs, heavy competition, and meaningful vulnerability to shifts in consumer behavior or economic conditions.

Fitness studios have produced some of the most striking numbers in SBA loan data. Orangetheory Fitness showed a 76 percent SBA loan default rate in data covering 2000 to 2016. Anytime Fitness carried the highest total number of charged-off loans among major franchise brands in the FY2020–2023 dataset. The pattern reflects a structural reality: gym memberships are among the first expenses consumers cut when budgets tighten, buildout costs for fitness concepts are substantial, and the space has become intensely competitive with both boutique studios and low-cost digital alternatives.

Fast casual and quick service restaurant concepts — particularly smaller or regional chains — consistently appear in high-default lists. Jon Smith Subs carries a 20 percent SBA loan default rate in VettedBiz’s analysis of FY2020–2023 data. Dickey’s Barbecue Pit has fared significantly worse — of 29 resolved SBA 7(a) loans from FY2010–2019, 19 were charged off. With a small sample, that ratio can shift with just a few loans, but the pattern is consistent with the brand’s presence on multiple high-default watchlists. Food concepts carry high overhead, thin margins, labor intensity, and relentless competition. The top-tier QSR brands with decades of operational history perform far better, but the category average is pulled up substantially by newer or weaker systems.

The common thread across high-default categories is that they depend on consumers choosing to spend money they don’t have to spend, combined with fixed overhead that continues whether customers show up or not.

Beyond financial risk, some franchise categories face an additional threat: technological disruption. Our analysis of franchise brands most vulnerable to AI identifies specific brands whose core value propositions are being replaced by artificial intelligence.

Brand Maturity Matters as Much as Category

Category selection is only part of the equation. Within any given industry, the difference between an established franchise system and a newer one can be wider than the difference between categories.

According to ROI Advisers’ analysis of SBA 7(a) loans from 2010 to 2021, the top 20 most-funded franchise brands had a combined default rate of just 4.3 percent. A separate FitSmallBusiness analysis of FY2020–2023 data found that fifteen of the twenty most-funded brands had zero charged-off loans during that period. The pattern is consistent across both datasets: established systems with decades of operational history default at a fraction of the overall franchise rate. Newer systems are still testing their models — often at the franchisee’s expense.

A well-established brand in a mid-tier category will frequently outperform a newer brand in a structurally strong category. A fifteen-year-old home services franchise with 400 locations and documented support infrastructure is a fundamentally different investment than a three-year-old brand in the same space with 40 locations still working out the details.

What This Means for a Specific Brand You’re Considering

This is where the general data stops being useful and the specific data becomes everything.

Every franchisor is required to provide a Franchise Disclosure Document before you sign anything. That document contains the actual operating history of the system — how many franchisees have opened, closed, transferred, or chosen not to renew. When a franchisor elects to provide it, it also includes financial performance data from operating locations. Reading those sections carefully reveals patterns that no aggregate statistic will show you: whether closure rates are trending up or down, whether franchisees are renewing or walking away, and whether the exits were voluntary or the result of financial distress.

For a step-by-step look at how this research fits into the broader evaluation process, see our guide to the franchise discovery process.

Most people don’t know what to look for in those documents. That’s not a criticism — they’re dense, the important numbers are buried in footnotes, and knowing what’s normal versus what’s a warning sign requires having read a lot of them. If you’re at the stage where you have a specific brand in front of you and want to know where it actually stands, that’s exactly what a first conversation with me covers.

Before that conversation, make sure you’re prepared with the 12 questions every prospective franchise buyer should ask. I’ll tell you what the disclosure document says, what it doesn’t say, and what I’d want to know before going further.

Book a free consultation — no commitment, no sales pitch on a specific brand.

The Failure Rate That Actually Matters

Industry averages give you a starting point. Brand maturity tells you something about execution risk. But the number that should drive your decision is the performance history of the specific system you’re evaluating, read against the current period, with your own financial situation and operational strengths factored in.

That analysis doesn’t exist in any article. It exists in the FDD, in conversations with current franchisees, and in an honest assessment of whether the unit economics work for you specifically. Anyone who tells you a franchise is safe or unsafe based on category alone is giving you half an answer.

The goal isn’t to make franchising sound risky or safe. It’s to make sure that when you decide, you’re deciding on the actual information.

Continue Your Research

More from our Decision Guide series:

Jason Ronnel, Certified Franchise Consultant
Jason RonnelCertified Franchise Consultant (CFC)

Jason Ronnel is a Certified Franchise Consultant credentialed through the International Franchise Professionals Group. He holds a finance degree from the University of Texas at Austin He maintains an active Texas real estate license. Jason has personally evaluated more than 700 franchise brands across dozens of industries, helping aspiring business owners find the right fit through personalized matchmaking, FDD analysis, and due diligence support. Book a free consultation.

Scroll to Top